Deepak wanted to see my rankings for 2010. The top of the year was very nice. The top 6 of the year were 6.75 and above which is very good for a year. Half of the Playmates were highly ranked and none were the PMOY which was a shame. Any of these girls would have been a great choice.
The next 5 were from 5.5 to 6. They were bunched together which is usual. Nothing really separated any of them. Each of them had their flaws, but they were average Playmates. Not bad choices, but they make you say “Next” when they appear. Now one tied Julianna Young for a 2.75. She actually went down from about a year ago when I originally did the rankings for 2010. When I do these, the ratings do change a little over time but not by much.
1) Jaime Edmondson 8.25
2) Amy Leigh Andrews 7.5
3) Francesca Frigo 7.25
4) Katie Vernola 7.25
5) Kyra Milan 7.0
6) Olivia Paige 6.75
7) Claire Sinclair 6.0
Heather Rae Young 6.0
9) Shera Bechard 5.75
10) Ashley Hobbs 5.5
11) Kassie Logsdon 5.5
12) Shanna McLaughlin 2.75
Jaime and Amy were by far my 2 favorites of the year. Jaime’s best feature are her legs which are just about perfect. They are long with great shape which comes from the workouts of being an NFL Cheerleader. Amy has nice breasts with nice legs and butt. I loved her when she was a Coed of the Month a year and a half earlier.
Francesca, Katie, and Kyra are very nice. Francesca and Kyra have great faces while Katie has some great breasts that fit her body very nicely. Olivia has a great slim body with nothing really outstanding, but she has no part of her that brings down the other. Olivia and Katie will no doubt be even better in a few year seeing they were 19 and 18 respectively when their issues came out.
Claire and Heather were nice but not that spectacular. Heather has nice long shapely legs while Claire has some nice breasts. Shera has some nice breasts with a decent ass while her legs one minute look nice but the next look too thin. Kassie has a face shaped like Jaime’s but not quite as striking while everything else is about average for a Playboy model.
Then we come to Shanna. Her face got a 5 which is average and the highest rated part. Her breasts don’t even come close to matching her body type. They just dominate her body too much. Her ass is pretty tiny without much shape while her legs are like toothpicks. They have no shape or form to them. I find it hard to believe that she won the Playboy Shootout over Olivia. There is no way that she should have been a Playmate. She brings the year down from a 6.61 to a 6.29. 6.6 is about average for both 1990′s and 2000′s, but instead, she brought it down to the worst in 2000′s and third worst in 1990′s. It is just like 2011 where the bottom 3 brought down the whole year.
ShannFann_01
*******************
Thanks for posting. Hope you can post the face-breasts-ass-legs breakup as well. Also would really like to see your ratings for 1987 if you haven’t lost them. Redoing them would not be easy. So let’s leave that out.
Agree about Jaime’s legs. Also think that Amy looked slightly better in her coed days because her face had that extra bit of sweetness that worked very well. Kyra probably has the best face of the year but I am not that convinced about Francesca’s face. Great point about Katie’s breasts being wonderful – noticed that a long time back and agree completely. Olivia has nothing outstanding – perhaps true but she is great in videos with expressive eyes, a nice smile and oodles of charm. Claire’s best feature is indeed her breasts. Shera I have said before looked better as Aurora Vaillantcourt of Mystique. True Kassie has a very ordinary body with below average breasts and ass but a really nice face coupled with a nice voice and a very sweet and pleasing disposition make her quite acceptable. Lastly I don’t think Shanna is that bad and would never compare her to Julianna Young but it’s all subjective of course.
Deepak
![[Valid RSS]](../valid-rss.png "Validate my RSS feed")
Claire Sinclair is the PMOY
That article was really enjoyable to read.
The author does make some valid points. Still Playboy has always said that PMOY is not a popularity but a business decision and solely Hef’s choice. However if the decision is made from before and even after that the vote is held then it’s an open case of deceit especially against those Playmates who tried hard to win fans’ votes.
Also for what it’s worth this article gave me information about Claire’s breakup. Not that I am the least bit surprised. It’s Hef’s son we are talking about. Surely this is the time he will move from woman to woman. However I did think that Claire may not be the favorite any more due to the breakup. It seems that’s not the case and the title had been promised to her long back.
Lastly this article mentioned a good point about trying to gauge popularity from the comments section. I just did that and roughly this is what were the results.
Jaime Faith Edmondson – 10 votes
Heather Rae Young – 4 votes
Kyra Milan – 4 votes
Amy Leigh Andrews – 8 votes
Kassie Lyn Logsdon – 2 votes
Katie Vernola – 7 votes
Shanna McLaughlin – 6 votes
Francesca Frigo – 8 votes
Olivia Paige – 10 votes
Claire Sinclair – 7 votes
Shera Bechard – 18 votes
Ashley Hobbs – 3 votes
> For you conspiracy theorists out there:
>
> http://pmoyisrigged.wordpress.com/2011/01/29/claire-sinclair-apparently-handed-pmoy-on-a-silver-platter/
>
> > For what it’s worth, someone added the info to Wikipedia:
> >
> > http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claire_Sinclair#October
> >
> > And though Claire hasn’t said so on her Twitter site (I’m sure someone at PB gave her a tongue lashing at spilling the beans), her fan site – http://twitter.com/Claire_SFans – reinforces the news flash.
> >
> > C’mon, what did you all expect? That someone truly worthy was going to win? Looks obvious to me….nepotism (Hef’s son’s g/f), plus Holly’s new bff, equals PMOY. the new virtual missive at Mansion West…fuck a Hefner, win a prize. Except if you’re name is Carrie Leigh…
> >
> > Another shovel-full of dirt on the Playboy grave…
> >
> > Q.E.D.
> > >
> > > *Claire won,I saw her last night on holly’s world TV show,she let the cat
> > > out of the bag. She said she did the photos for PMOY.*
> > >
> > > On Mon, Apr 4, 2011 at 3:51 AM, Deepak <jdeepak14@> wrote:
> > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > > > Oh. Are they allowed to reveal long before it becomes official?